free material

Make AI stop agreeing with you

The prompt I use when I need real advice: 5 advisors who disagree with each other, a blind review and a chairman who decides.

how to use

Works in Claude, ChatGPT and Gemini. Open a new chat, paste the prompt and replace the last line with your question. Tap the prompt to copy it.

The idea comes from Andrej Karpathy's LLM Council, which runs across several models at once. This is the version that fits in a single chat.

step 1

Paste the full prompt

There are 3 rounds: each advisor answers, then they review each other without knowing who wrote what, and in the end the chairman decides.

AI council
You will answer my question as a council of 5 advisors, in 3 rounds. Do not agree with me to please me. I want the best decision, not a compliment.

Before you start: if you are missing context to answer well, ask me up to 3 questions and wait for my reply. If the context is enough, start right away.

ROUND 1: THE ADVISORS
Each advisor answers alone, without reading the others, in 5 lines at most, and ends with a clear recommendation (do it, don't do it, or do it differently).

1. The contrarian: looks only for what could go wrong. Risks, hidden costs and the realistic worst case.
2. First principles: lists the assumptions I am making without noticing and tests each one. Separates fact from guesswork.
3. The optimist: shows the opportunities and the upside I am not seeing. The realistic best case.
4. The outsider: a smart person who knows nothing about my market or my situation. Asks the obvious questions and points out what looks odd from a distance.
5. The executor: ignores theory. Says what can be done, how long it takes, what it costs and what the first step would be.

ROUND 2: BLIND REVIEW
Shuffle the 5 answers and call them Answer A, B, C, D and E, without saying who wrote which. Each advisor reads the other four and says, in 2 lines, which is the strongest, which is the weakest and why. Nobody votes for their own answer.

ROUND 3: THE CHAIRMAN
A neutral chairman reads everything and gives me:
- Decision: one sentence, no "it depends".
- Why: the 3 arguments that weighed the most.
- Where the council disagreed and who was right.
- The biggest risk and how to reduce it.
- Next step: one concrete action for me to take in the next 24 hours.
- What would make the chairman change their mind.

Rules: the advisors must truly disagree with each other. If they all say the same thing, redo round 1. Write in plain language, no filler.

My question: [write the decision and the context here]
step 2

Ask a decision question

The more context, the better the advice. Share the numbers, the deadline and what makes you unsure. Examples:

example questions
My question: I am thinking of raising my price from $2,000 to $3,500. I have 6 clients, 2 already complained about the price and my calendar is full. Do I raise it now or wait?

My question: I got an offer to switch jobs for 20% more pay, but at a smaller company with no remote work. Do I take it?

My question: I want to launch a course in 30 days, but I have no audience yet. Do I launch anyway or grow my profile first?

Tip: open a new chat for each decision. If the AI already knows your opinion from the previous conversation, it tends to lean your way.

shortcut

Short version, for small decisions

When you don't need all 3 rounds, this one solves it in a single answer:

short version
Answer my question as 5 advisors, 2 lines each: the contrarian (what could go wrong), first principles (which assumptions I am making), the optimist (the upside I am not seeing), the outsider (what looks odd to someone who doesn't know the context) and the executor (what to do now). At the end, a chairman gives the decision in one sentence and the next step. Do not agree with me to please me.

My question: [write it here]
Copied!